![]() |
![]() |
|
November 30, 2003Tablet Coming From Apple?Well, Kevin over at Lockergnome has posted an interesting blog entry about the possibility that Apple might be coming out with a Tablet PC. That could be very interesting... if Apple can make it as slick as the Inking API that Microsoft has. On that note though... I am not sure how well the whole Tablet idea will work out. Scoble has always drank the MS Tablet Koolaid and spews a lot about it... but I can say first hand after spending a week with him, that it is unrealistic to tout the Tablet as an end all solution. Why do I say that? Because during the whole week I was with him, he didn't use his TabletPC once while I was around. Hell, it wouldn't even boot up when I tried it in his office at Microsoft. When I recommended that we blog while watching a movie (all hail Wireless Access Points!) I was politely told that he only blogs from his machine in his home office. (He has a special Thinkpad dedicated to it). When we were walking around he never carried it with him, even though I had my laptop with me always... and blogged everywhere. (Microsoft has wireless AP almost everywhere I was on campus, which was really nice) His reasonings for why he doesn't use his Tablet were sound.. in that he is never more than 30 minutes from a desktop computer, and he is more productive on those machines, especially due to screen real estate. But you have to put that into context. He would prefer to be chained to a desktop than the freedom of the Tablet with wireless... because he is more productive on the desktop. And that makes total sense. Dual head 21 inch monitors will typically beat out a single 14 inch lcd for many people... especially when the CPU is slower than most people's regular laptops. Now comes Apple into the mix. Alan tells me that Expose kicks total butt when it comes to Window management in OSX Panther.... which means that potentially, the workspace productivity hole may be plugged. Who knows. If Apple does come out with this in the new year, it will be interesting to see. I wonder if we would think of it as a Newton on steroids? Here is a challenge for ANY TabletPC vendor out there that believes they have the end all solution. I write code quite a bit, as well as do security audits and forensic analysis on a regular basis. I take a lot of notes, write documents regularly, do tonnes of flow charting and code to the bone. Lend me a reasonably powerful machine that can handle the likes of Visual Studio .NET, Office XP etc... and I will use it for 1 quarter (3 months) as my primary system. I will blog about my experiences on a regular basis and show everyone an unbiased view on how productive it can be for regular technology power users like myself. It doesn't have to be the prettiest thing, and it doesn't have to be new. But it has to be what you are selling to customers like me. Why the challenge? Because it is safe to bet no one will take me up on it. (That and I doubt any Tablet companies read my blog). If someone does, I would really like to put it through the paces... and possibly end with writing a few Inking apps that would be useful for me in my field of work. I know a few other information security professionals that have thought of using a Tablet during vulnerability assessments and site surveys... and what would be a better recommendation than from their peers? If you want to take me up on my challenge, fire me an email. Please don't fire me emails if you are going to expect me to hail to the godliness of your TabletPC use... as I heard that already from Robert.... yet never saw him use it once. Proof is in the pudding. And I would prefer to eat my own. Posted by SilverStr at November 30, 2003 11:53 AM | TrackBackComments
I would say that there IS a use for Tablet PCs. It doesn't necessarily have to be for personal use such as reading e-books or taking notes. My customer bought several 17" LCD screens and very small computers, strictly for barcoding. Because this was 4-5 years ago when embedded computers, LCDs etc were just becoming mainstream, they were expensive: something in the low 5 digits. If they had the options available then that they have today, they probably would have gone for for Table PCs. Here are some example devices that are factory rugged, do barcoding/RFID/magnetic swipe, etc: Posted by: Wim at December 1, 2003 05:33 AMI would be interested to see what would have happened if you had borrowed the tablet for the time and used it and actually been able to see how it works In Real Life. I think tablets might be one of those things like touchscreens that people go "oh that's fucking cool" but when it comes time to actually use them, they find that they just don't work as well. Interesting about Robert, I got the impression he was chained to his tablet from the way he talks.... Posted by: Arcterex at December 1, 2003 07:40 AMQuote>> Ya, so did I. To be fair, Robert did say he uses it when going to meetings at Microsoft all the time... and some people who work with technology all day may not want to carry it with them everywhere. But I found it truly odd that his Tablet wouldn't boot up, and I never actually saw him use it. Its one thing to talk the talk.... its another to walk the walk. Posted by: SilverStr at December 1, 2003 08:15 AMWe briefly looked at adding TablePC to our app at Fred Hutch CRC. If all you are going to do is put checkmarks in checkboxes or select items from drop down lists, it's a great tool. For every day data entry and reporting it's really clunky for the end user. I've always seen TabletPCs as a new input device for a desktop PC rather than an independant, functioning PC. I thought they would have bluetooth or WiFi support built in and a device driver for windows that would act like a terminal/VNC server, allowing me to just pick up the tablet and take it with me to bed/easy chair/deck/whatever and continue reading whatever I was reading (or watching). Use one for serious work? Too clunky. Scott - interesting. I talked to Dana a bit on IM and basically I will believe it when I see it as far as the tablet being useful beyond the "oh cool" factor. I'm not yet convinced it has advantages over a desktop or laptop for some things. For inventory checking, or data entry with a scanner or something and wandering around a warehouse ticking things off, definately, but I write way slower than I type, so doing data entry is out, and scratching notes that are uploaded to a central server is nifty and all, but is a $3000 device (or however much they are) doing this vs a $0.0000001 sheet of paper and then just typing out my notes with a laptop or desktop when I get back to the office.... I'd love to have one to try out for a while and see if it actually helps me or hinders me. Having someone tell me how cool it is doesn't do much for me. Posted by: Arcterex at December 1, 2003 10:44 AMapple's market is just too small to support the tablet idea unless they market it outside of the traditional pc relm like with the ipod. hate to say it because i would love to see what aple would come up with. Posted by: fozbaca at December 2, 2003 06:08 AM |
![]() ![]()
My 5 Favorite Books
Writing Secure Code
Secure Programming Cookbook Security Engineering Secure Coding Principles & Practice Inside the Security Mind ![]()
My 5 Favorite Papers
Smashing the Stack
Penetration Studies Covert Channel Analysis of Trusted Systems DoD Trusted Computer System Evaluation Criteria NSA Security Recommendation Guides ![]()
Archives
September 2007
August 2007 July 2007 June 2007 May 2007 April 2007 March 2007 February 2007 January 2007 December 2006 November 2006 October 2006 September 2006 August 2006 July 2006 June 2006 May 2006 April 2006 March 2006 February 2006 January 2006 December 2005 November 2005 October 2005 September 2005 August 2005 July 2005 June 2005 May 2005 April 2005 March 2005 February 2005 January 2005 December 2004 November 2004 October 2004 September 2004 August 2004 July 2004 June 2004 May 2004 April 2004 March 2004 February 2004 January 2004 December 2003 November 2003 October 2003 September 2003 August 2003 July 2003 June 2003 May 2003 April 2003 March 2003 February 2003 January 2003 December 2002 November 2002 October 2002 September 2002 August 2002 July 2002 ![]() |
|